Tyler Shough is the other half of New Orleans' QB race, drafted in the second round, noted for struggles in preseason. His fate will determine Week 1’s offensive ceiling, with the article highlighting his inconsistent performance as the Saints search for a reliable starter.

Tyler Shough sits in the Saints’ QB duel, delivering a solid 24/34 for 231 yards with 1 TD and 1 INT across two preseason games. His multi‐program college background (Oregon, Texas Tech, Louisville) and pro‐style frame keep him in the upstairs of Moore’s decision, presenting a high ceiling if he threads Moore’s offense effectively from Week 1 forward.

Shough, the second-round pick, is the Saints’ other QB option. He’s shown accuracy and poise but remains a rookie behind an aging Carr era. His two preseason games reveal a capable arm with room to grow in experience and playbook familiarity, and his ability to manage teams late in drives could decide the race.

Shough has posted 70.6% on 231 yards with 1 TD and 1 INT, while being sacked four times. His arm talent and tempo have kept him in a tight competition with Rattler, creating a realistic Week 1 starter debate for Moore.

Shough has shared starter duties with Rattler in the Saints’ exhibitions, posting 24-of-34 for 232 yards with 1 TD and 1 INT across two games. His rookie status and continued rotation keep the job from feeling closed, maintaining a high-stakes dynamic for fantasy implications and Week 1 planning should he win the role.